Willie Mays – The 1952 Topps
Along with the Mantle card, Willie Mays also appears in the 1952 Topps set as the New York center fielder. Overall, this man was a Hall of Famer at the time, so his card sells for about $478,000. At least, it did at an auction in 2016!
Kirby Puckett – The 1984 Fleer Update
Those who have the 1984 Fleer Update set might also have Kirby Puckett in there. The Hall of Famer can go for a lot, but it depends primarily on the grade. Generally, this Minnesota player sells for $200 to $500 (perfect condition).